Tuesday, 15 January 2008

Unintended consequences file

From Johan Norberg's blog
23:49 - GOOD INTENTIONS CREATE CHILD PROSTITUTION:

Some of us have warned that banning child labour might force children into worse circumstances. Via Hårek Hansen I find a report from Norwegian television, where a respected Danish NGO explains that this is what they have just seen in Bangladesh:
"Due to Western pressure, Bangladesh outlawed work in garment factories for children under 14.

- When the children lost their jobs, many of them ended up on the streets, as prostitutes. We know that much, says Rasmus Juhl Pedersen, adviser in Save the Children, Denmark.

Somewhere between 30.000 and 100.000 children lost their jobs when the garment factories introduced the age limit.

To work as a prostitute, maid or further down the line of production is much worse than working in the garment industry, according to Juhl Pedersen.

Western companies are so afraid of being associated with child labour that the children are thrown out of the factories even though no one has prepared any alternatives.

Well-meaning western consumers who boycott products that can be tied to child labour can do more harm than good, according to Save the Children, Denmark.”

(Translation by Norberg)

1 comment:

Eric Crampton said...

My sister is touring Cambodia. She posted on her visit to an orphanage for kids who'd been garbage pickers in the dumps. Then she visited the dumps. When the alternative to labour in a relatively safe factory is child prostitution or scrambling barefoot through garbage dumps looking for salvageable scrap, it's heartless to close the factories.

She blogs on here visit here.